Mailshake and Instantly both send cold email, but they charge for different things. Mailshake bills per user and puts a dialer and LinkedIn steps in its $99 Sales Engagement plan; Instantly bills per workspace, lets you connect unlimited mailboxes and caps emails and contacts by tier. Pick Mailshake if a few reps want email, calls and LinkedIn in one tool; pick Instantly if you scale by adding mailboxes.
For the deep dive on one side, read our Mailshake review.
Some tool links here are affiliate links (disclosure). Nerdy Joe is an affiliate of both Mailshake and Instantly, so we earn whichever you choose, and we recommend by use case. We are not an Instantly partner beyond that affiliate link.
We have not tested either tool hands-on for this comparison. Mailshake facts come from its own pages read November 20, 2026, Instantly prices from its pricing page the same day, and other Instantly details from our October 2026 Instantly review. You can see Mailshake's plans or start an Instantly free trial to check live figures.
Mailshake vs Instantly at a glance
| Mailshake | Instantly | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per user | Per workspace, unlimited email accounts |
| Entry plan | Starter $29 ($25 yearly): 1 address, 1,500 sends a month | Growth $47 ($37.60 yearly): 5,000 emails, 1,000 contacts |
| Mid plan | Email Outreach $49 ($45 yearly): 2 addresses, unlimited sends | Hypergrowth $107 ($85.58 yearly) |
| Top published plan | Sales Engagement $99 ($85 yearly): 10 addresses, dialer, LinkedIn | Light Speed $358 ($286.30 yearly) |
| Agency | Agency plan, unlimited addresses, Talk to Sales | Extra workspaces and white label from Hypergrowth (October review) |
| Contacts | Unlimited uploaded contacts on all plans | Capped by plan, total that does not reset (October review) |
| Warmup | Unlimited, all plans | Unlimited, all Outreach plans |
| Lead data | Data Finder add-on $19 ($17 yearly), 50 or 2,500 credits included | SuperSearch via separate credits, Growth Credits $47 a month |
| Dialer | Power dialer and 5 numbers on Sales Engagement | No calling steps in sequences (October review) |
| Messages, connection requests, profile views on Sales Engagement | No LinkedIn steps in sequences (October review) | |
| Free trial | None | 14 days, no credit card (October review) |
| Refunds | Terms say all fees are nonrefundable | Third parties report non-refundable fees (October review) |
Prices are as of November 2026 and in US dollars. Instantly's Hypergrowth price rose from $97 in our October review to $107 on the pricing page we read in November.
Pricing: per seat vs flat workspace
Mailshake's pricing FAQ says billing "is based on how many users you purchase." Instantly's plans are per workspace, and every Outreach plan includes unlimited connected email accounts, so more volume means more mailboxes, not more licenses.
The cost gap depends on how you grow. The table below is our arithmetic from published prices on monthly billing, before mailboxes, domains, data or tax.
| Scenario | Mailshake | Instantly |
|---|---|---|
| 1 founder, 1 mailbox, under 1,500 emails a month | Starter, $29 | Growth, $47 |
| 1 founder, 2 mailboxes, unified inbox | Email Outreach, $49 | Growth, $47 (cannot reply from Unibox on Growth, per our October review) |
| 3 reps, email only | 3 Email Outreach seats, $147 | Hypergrowth, $107 (team invites need Hypergrowth) |
| 3 reps, email plus calls and LinkedIn | 3 Sales Engagement seats, $297 | Not offered as sequence steps |
| 1 operator, 20 mailboxes | Between $198 and $980, depending on how Mailshake counts mailboxes (see below) | Growth $47 or Hypergrowth $107, depending on email volume |
That last row needs explaining. Mailshake's FAQ says "With each user you pay for, your team may connect 1 mail account," while its plan cards list 1, 2 and 10 email addresses. On the FAQ reading, 20 mailboxes means 20 Email Outreach seats ($980); on the card reading, two Sales Engagement seats ($198) cover them.
We report both because Mailshake's pages disagree, and our Mailshake pricing breakdown lays out every conflict.
Instantly has its own fine print. Growth caps you at 5,000 emails and 1,000 uploaded contacts, and our October review found that its contact limit is a running total that does not reset each month. Lead data, the CRM and placement tests are separate subscriptions.
Annual billing helps on both. Our Mailshake review explains what each Mailshake tier includes beyond price. Mailshake's yearly prices save about 8% to 14% by our arithmetic, and Instantly's Outreach plans show about 20% off ($47 to $37.60 on Growth).
Sending model and limits
Mailshake gives Starter a cap of 1,500 sends a month and lists unlimited sends on the higher plans. Its help center (last updated May 13, 2021) gives provider limits of 500 a day for Gmail and 2,000 for Google Workspace, and Mailshake caps Microsoft and SMTP accounts at 1,000 a day.
Mailshake's scheduling guidance is conservative. A March 2025 help article says "We DO NOT recommend increasing from 20 emails per day to 300 emails per day," recommends at least 5 minutes between sends, and suggests ramping one email per time slot in week one, two in week two and three in week three.
Instantly limits emails per month by plan rather than per seat and rotates sends across every connected mailbox. That suits teams that grow by adding inboxes on many domains, which is how most cold email volume is built. Our guide on how many inboxes you need for cold email shows the math.
Instantly's Growth plan, per our October review, does not let you reply from the unified inbox, add subsequences or invite team members. For most teams, Hypergrowth at $107 is the realistic starting point, which narrows the price gap with Mailshake for small teams.
Warmup
Both include unlimited warmup. Mailshake's warmup help article says it sends warmup emails to Mailshake-owned addresses with automated replies and marks spam-folder hits as not spam. It advises waiting 7 or more days after creating a domain, connecting one address first and adding the rest after about a month, and warming 1 to 2 weeks before outreach.
Instantly's warmup page, per our October review, describes a network of 1M+ real accounts, with headless browsers that open and scroll through messages and a slow daily ramp. Its Standard Warmup Pool has an SMTP account limit by plan (100, 500 or 1,000 accounts in October).
Neither vendor publishes independent placement data for its warmup. Warmup is a reputation signal, not a guarantee, so watch real campaign replies and bounces rather than warmup scores alone.
Lead data
Mailshake Data Finder "offers data for over 100+ million prospects," searchable by job title, company, industry and location. It costs $19 a month or $17 yearly, and Mailshake's pricing page also lists 50 free credits on Starter and Email Outreach and 2,500 on Sales Engagement.
There is a conflict here: the Data Finder page says the paid add-on has "Unlimited credits," while the pricing page lists per-plan credit allowances. We report both rather than pick one.
Instantly SuperSearch is listed at 450M+ contacts on the pricing page (our October review found 610M+ in the help center). It runs on Instantly credits sold separately; the pricing page lists Growth Credits at $47 a month. Our October review found a verified work email costs about 1.5 credits on average, and unused credits expire.
Neither vendor publishes accuracy data, so verify every list before you send. Our guide to B2B data providers compares dedicated data tools if you want data outside your sender.
Dialer and phone
This is the clearest feature gap. Mailshake's Sales Engagement plan includes a power phone dialer, 5 phone numbers and phone scripts, and its February 2026 dialer launch post describes one-click browser calling, call recording and CRM sync.
Mailshake's dialer cost article (July 30, 2025) says each Sales Engagement user gets 100 free minutes a month, that calls to the US, Canada, the UK and several other countries are free and uncounted, and that numbers are available only in the US, Canada and Australia. International minutes beyond that are billed through $50 automatic top-ups, which are non-refundable.
Instantly, per our October review, has no calling steps inside sequences. Its CRM records calls and SMS, and a Voice Agent launched in September 2026 calls inbound leads, which is a different job from a rep working an outbound call list.
Mailshake automates LinkedIn messages, connection requests and profile views on the Sales Engagement plan through its Chrome extension, and its help center says browser windows must stay open while tasks run. The daily limits conflict across its own pages: the product page says the default is 20 messages, 10 connection requests and 10 profile views a day, adjustable to 100, while the help article says Mailshake limits messages to 10 a day.
Instantly does not offer LinkedIn steps in sequences, per our October review. Teams on Instantly typically add a separate LinkedIn tool; our roundup of LinkedIn automation tools covers the options.
Any LinkedIn automation carries account risk. LinkedIn's User Agreement prohibits bots and other unauthorized automated methods to add contacts or send messages, so keep volumes conservative on either setup.
AI, integrations and agency features
AI. Mailshake's SHAKEspeare, on all paid plans, builds a 6-email cold sequence from your business description and success stories, in English only. Instantly has a broader agent lineup, including Copilot and an AI Reply Agent billed at 5 credits per reply, per our October review.
CRM. Mailshake lists Salesforce, Pipedrive and HubSpot integrations plus Zapier on Email Outreach and up, but not on Starter. Instantly integrates with HubSpot, Pipedrive, Zapier and Make, and our October review found Salesforce runs only through a third-party connector.
API. Mailshake publishes API docs, and its help center says it "isn't able to create custom API solutions at this time." Instantly's API V2 starts on Growth, per our October review.
Agencies. Mailshake's FAQ recommends each client create its own team as the billed party and add the agency as a user, and its Agency plan (unpriced) lists unlimited email addresses. Instantly offers extra workspaces and white label from Hypergrowth, with each client workspace on its own subscription.
Verdict by use case
| Use case | Our pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Solo founder, one mailbox, low volume | Mailshake Starter | $29 against $47, if 1,500 sends a month is enough |
| Reps who call and use LinkedIn alongside email | Mailshake Sales Engagement | Dialer, 5 numbers and LinkedIn tasks in one plan |
| Salesforce team that wants a native connector | Mailshake | Native Salesforce from Email Outreach up |
| Scaling by adding many mailboxes | Instantly | Unlimited email accounts on a flat workspace price |
| Teams that want to try before paying | Instantly | 14-day trial with no card; Mailshake has none |
| Built-in lead database with AI agents | Instantly | Larger listed database and more AI agents, paid in credits |
| Agencies with many client workspaces | Instantly | Workspaces and white label from Hypergrowth; Mailshake's Agency plan is unpriced |
| Uploading very large lists | Mailshake | Unlimited uploaded contacts on all plans |
If you want to try both, the order is simple: start Instantly's free trial to test the workflow, and check Mailshake's Sales Engagement plan if calls and LinkedIn matter. The Mailshake vs Smartlead and Mailshake vs lemlist comparisons cover two other common choices.
Before you commit to Mailshake, read the full Mailshake review, because there is no trial and fees are nonrefundable. When you are ready, pick a Mailshake plan on monthly billing, or compare Mailshake's tiers once more. On Instantly, see Instantly's current plans and match the email and contact caps to your volume.
Rather not run outbound yourself?
Either tool sends the email. Lists, copy, mailbox health and reply handling are still the weekly work.
Nerdy Joe is owned by Agency Growth Partners (AGP). AGP builds lists, runs campaigns and books meetings for agencies, so if you would rather hand that off, book a call with David.
Disclosure: My relationship with Instantly is that of an independent party. I do not hold any position, nor do I have the power to form binding agreements or act on behalf of Instantly. My earnings are derived from referral compensations provided by Instantly. The views I share are solely mine and should not be seen as official statements, promises, or representations of Instantly, or any related entities or personnel.
Sources
- Mailshake pricing
- Mailshake homepage
- Mailshake Data Finder
- Mailshake LinkedIn automation
- Mailshake blog: power dialer launch
- Mailshake terms
- Mailshake Help: how does LinkedIn automation work
- Mailshake Help: how much does the phone dialer cost
- Mailshake Help: how does Warm Up Your Email work
- Mailshake Help: how many emails can I send per day
- Mailshake Help: how can I tweak sending schedules
- Mailshake Help: how does SHAKEspeare work
- Mailshake Help: using the API to sync to other platforms
- Instantly pricing
- LinkedIn User Agreement
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between Mailshake and Instantly?
Mailshake bills per user and adds a dialer and LinkedIn steps on its Sales Engagement plan. Instantly bills per workspace with unlimited connected email accounts and caps monthly emails and uploaded contacts by plan instead.
Is Mailshake or Instantly cheaper?
For one person with one mailbox, Mailshake Starter is cheaper at $29 a month against Instantly Growth at $47, as of November 2026. Once a team needs many mailboxes or several users, Instantly's flat workspace price usually costs less, because Mailshake charges per seat.
Does Instantly have a dialer and LinkedIn automation like Mailshake?
Not as sequence steps, per our October 2026 Instantly review. Mailshake's Sales Engagement plan includes a power dialer, 5 phone numbers and LinkedIn tasks; Instantly's CRM tracks calls and LinkedIn connections, and its Voice Agent calls inbound leads.
Do Mailshake and Instantly have free trials?
Instantly offers a 14-day free trial with no credit card. Mailshake does not; its pricing FAQ says "No, we collect payment up front."
Which has more lead data, Mailshake or Instantly?
Mailshake says Data Finder covers over 100 million prospects and sells it as a $19 a month add-on, with some credits included per plan. Instantly lists SuperSearch at 450M+ contacts on its pricing page, paid with separately sold credits.
Is Nerdy Joe an affiliate of Mailshake and Instantly?
Yes. Nerdy Joe is an affiliate of both and may earn from purchases through our links, which is why we recommend by use case rather than naming one winner.